Castro Valley High School’s award-winning student newspaper. We are born to seek the truth!

Opinion

Rapists deserve more punishment

When someone commits a crime as awful as rape, he should not get the privilege of being treated with sympathy.

However, in Brock Turner’s case, the judge gave only half of the maximum sentence for that crime to the Stanford swimmer. In addition, after only serving half of his shortened sentence, he got to go free.

Convicted of sexual assault, Turner committed a violent crime that will scar the victim’s life forever. He should not be able to get off so easily.

Towards the beginning of the year, Turner was found in the process of sexually assaulting an unconscious young woman on Stanford grounds by two passersby, who proceeded to chase and tackle him to the ground after he tried to flee. He was sentenced to six months in jail and was then released after serving only three months of his sentence on Sept. 2.

His father wrote that his son’s life shouldn’t be ruined “for 20 minutes of action.” What about the life he ruined when he attacked that young woman? Victims of rape do not just get over the experience. They were violated in one of the most heinous ways possible and they suffer psychological trauma that will stay with them for a very long time.

Trauma also comes with people who say that the girls “asked for it” or “brought it on themselves.” Girls do not ask to get raped, sexually assaulted or violated physically any other type of way. The real crime is that a lot of girls who go to court for rape have to prove that they was actually raped and that they did not give consent to their attackers. The experience of rape is enough of a burden without the victims having to prove their innocence. The attackers should be on trial, not them.

Knowing that the people who ruined their lives are locked away can be a form of relief for victims. However, Turner’s victim does not even have that satisfaction. And while Turner is listed as a sex offender and on a three-year probation, his life will only be slightly more difficult, as he might not being able to find a job easily and will not be going back to Stanford.

The part that makes this even worse is that Turner was arrested for sexual assault, not rape. California law’s definitions of rape and sexual assault are different, and the actions that Turner took fall under the sexual assault category. In my opinion, rape is rape, and I’m not the only one who thinks that.

Many people want California change its definition of rape to help cases like these become more clear.

Something as awful as rape should be an open and shut case, not something to be debated. The victim has been traumatized enough and should be spared the painful process of having to prove that she was assaulted. Hopefully California will change its laws so cases like these won’t have to go through so many steps to get the assailant behind bars, and hopefully, they will stay there for longer than three months.

5 thoughts on “Rapists deserve more punishment

  • Sarah Navarro

    Your article caught my attention because you didn’t say “we should stop rapists”. This act of assault is one of the worst things to do to another human being, and unfortunately affects a lot of people in our lifetime. We know that no matter how bad it is, it still happens. So “stopping” rapist would be not possible. I agree with you that they deserve a longer punishment, and much longer than what Turner received. Because the act they commit wasn’t an accident. It was planned and thought out. They deserve to know that what they did won’t be forgotten or forgiven.

  • Madeleine Aahl

    You do a very good job at explaining why rapist deserve more punishment and I completely agree with your argument because often times these rapist are sentence a short term in prison, and then repeat the crime shortly after they are released while the victim is left with a lifetime of trauma. However, one thing I noticed is that in your opening sentence, you are very quick to identify someone who commits rape as, “he.” Be careful not to objectify men because even though most of the rape cases we hear about through the media are acts of men, there are certainly women who commit these horrendous acts as well. Overall, this is a well written argument and I’m glad that the way that the court handles these cases angers you as much as it angers me.

  • Jeffrey Jiang

    I absolutely agree with your argument. Rapists definitely deserve more jail time, taking into consideration the severity of the crime that they commit.

  • Hamza Saad

    I agree with your article, Brock Turner got off with such a light punishment. He committed rape and rapists should be locked up in jail for a lot longer than three months.

  • Maritza Ramirez

    I agree with your article and it really caught my attention. Rapist do deserve to serve the time given to them whether it was a mistake or intentionally. Especially as an adult, everyone makes mistakes and it’s understandable but not forgivable. He needed to own up to what he did because that is not in any way acceptable. Very good , I’m really glad you touched this topic.

Comments are closed.